HER's Letter drops every Tuesday — Subscribe free →

HOW TO CATCH A CATFISH

Suspicion isn't proof. But it is permission to look closer. Here's exactly how.

You don't need to be a private investigator to verify someone's identity online. You need a few free tools, about 20 minutes, and the willingness to find out what's actually there.

Step 1: Run a Reverse Image Search on Every Photo

Go to images.google.com and drag in their profile photo, or right-click and select "Search image." Also try TinEye.com — it searches a different database and sometimes catches what Google misses.

Look for the same image appearing under a different name, originating from a stock photo site, or appearing in a foreign social media account.

HER Hold Up

Run every photo they've shared — profile photos, photos sent in messages, photos from their social accounts. Catfishers often pull from multiple sources, so one photo clearing the search doesn't mean the others will.

Step 2: Search Their Name + Key Details Together

Open Google and search their full name combined with their claimed city, workplace, and profession. Try: "John Smith Denver engineer," "John Smith Denver LinkedIn." A real person with a real professional life will usually surface somewhere. If nothing comes up for someone who claims to be established in their career, that absence is its own kind of information.

Step 3: Cross-Reference Their Social Media

Look at when the account was created, how many connections they have, whether people who know them interact in the comments, and whether the post history goes back more than a year. Real social accounts have natural messiness — old posts, friend interactions, photo evolution over time. Manufactured accounts tend to be thin, consistent, and suspiciously polished.

Step 4: Run a Background Check on the Information They've Given You

Use the name, age, and location they've given you. A background check will surface whether that combination matches actual public records — address history, criminal records, known associates, and phone number verification.

ServiceBest ForPriceNotes
BeenVerified Best OverallFull identity check~$27/moDeepest US data pool, clean interface
Social CatfishImage + username verify~$28/moBuilt specifically for catching catfishers
SpokeoEmail + social lookup~$20/moStrong if you only have an email or username
TruthFinderCriminal records~$29/moMost thorough criminal database

Step 5: Verify Their Phone Number

Free tools like TrueCaller can tell you whether a phone number is registered to the name they gave you, and whether it's a VoIP number — commonly used by catfishers to avoid leaving a real identity trail.

Step 6: Propose a Real-Time Video Call — Without Warning

Don't schedule it. Just ask now: "Can you jump on a quick video call right now?" Their response tells you a lot. Genuine availability may vary, but genuine interest will always find a way within a reasonable window. A pattern of immediate deflection is a pattern.

HER Hold Up

If they do video call, pay attention. Does the background look artificial or inconsistent with where they claim to live? Is the quality deliberately poor in a way that makes verification hard? Your instincts about whether what you're seeing matches what you've been told are usually right.

Step 7: Trust What the Evidence Shows

If the checks come back inconsistent — photos that don't match, a background check that finds nothing under their name, a phone number tied to a VoIP service — that's information. Act on it. The emotional investment you've made doesn't change what the evidence shows. Knowing now costs less than knowing later.

HER's Letters — Every Tuesday

The check, the red flag HER noticed, and one question worth asking before you go further.

Every Tuesday · Free · Unsubscribe in one click

Talking to someone helps. Actually.

HER vetted it. Online-Therapy.com pairs you with a licensed therapist in your state — sessions are online, affordable, and they won't make you talk about your childhood for six months before getting to the point.

Start Therapy →

Affiliate link — HER earns a small commission at no cost to you.

Legal disclaimer: Check Her First is not an attorney, licensed investigator, or mental health professional. Content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, psychological, or investigative advice. Background check affiliate links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. US laws vary by state. Consult a licensed professional for your specific situation.